Steak with Mushroom Sauce (Steak Aux Champignons)

April 3, 2009 · View Comments

in Beef, French Recipes

Steak with mushroom sauce, riced yukon gold potatoes and char grilled spring onion

After a rather productive week in the kitchen last week, I’ve been feeling wholly uninspired this week. Call it a case of chef’s-block, or cooking apathy, but the mere act of getting myself into the kitchen has felt like chore. I even had a bout with a nagging craving for bad Chinese food, which I finally relented to and sated with a $5 plate of greasy chow fun from around the corner.

Not even my inspiration generating tactics were working, and I started to worry about my ability to feed L and I. So I did what anyone would do in such a predicament and went back to basics, deciding on steak with riced potatoes. Normally, I wouldn’t bore you with a post on something so mundane, but this one deserved its own post for two reasons: I’ve developed a method to cook steak perfectly every time, and the mushroom sauce I served on top was exceptionally delicious.

Filet Mignon salted and peppered

So what’s my secret for a perfect steak? Beyond the usual points like using a very hot pan and salting liberally, I have two tips.

  1. Use a room temperature piece of meat. It prevents the problem of getting a steak with a tough, overcooked exterior and a cold, raw interior. A steak that’s straight from the fridge has an internal temperature of about 35 degrees. To get it to rare, you need to raise the internal temperature to 120 degrees. That’s an 85 degree change that has to happen quickly, so you don’t overcook the exterior. By getting the steak to about 70 degrees before you start cooking it, you only need to raise the internal temperature about 50 degrees.
  2. After searing the steak, put it in a hot oven, then turn it off. With no direct heat source, the steak will gently cook to your desired level of doneness slowly. More importantly, it’s almost impossible to over cook it, since the heat is turned off. The first time I tried this method, I accidentally forgot about the steak, and it was in the oven for nearly 20 minutes. At first, I was livid because my dry aged steak was brownish-pink all the way through, but upon biting into it, I was pleasantly surprised at how moist and tender it was.

The pan sauce is just an emulsion of reduced stock and butter, but the brown fond in the pan from the steak combined with a double dose of shallots and mushrooms gives it a serious wallop of flavour that will tickle your umami tastebuds.

Riced Potatoes

I served this with riced yukon gold potatoes. If you don’t have a ricer, stop reading and go get one. They look like a giant garlic press, and they’re much faster/easier to use than a masher. You don’t even have to peel the potatoes after boiling them since the skins won’t go through the holes.

The blurry twirl in the back of the photo at the top of the page is a char-grilled spring onion. This is a beautiful thing that may just have the best effort-to-tastiness ratio of any vegetable dish. Just wash a few spring onions (sweet onions, picked in early spring when they are still young), and put them a few inches from the broiler until the outer layer is charred black all around. Don’t worry, you want them to look scary burnt. Put the smoking onions into a pot and cover with a lid. The residual heat cooks the onion all the way through and the smoke coming from the charred exterior infuses the whole thing with a wonderful aroma. When you’re ready to serve, just crumble off the charred outer layer and you’ll expose the smoky, caramelized onion within. Sprinkle with sea salt and a splash of olive oil and you’re good to go.

2 1.5″ thick filet mignon steaks
coarse cracked black pepper
kosher salt

1 C wild mushrooms (I used shimeji mushrooms)
2 shallots minced
2 Tbs cognac
3/4 C low sodium chicken stock
1 Tbs butter
lemon juice

Bring the steaks to room temperature (about 30 minutes). Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.

When the steaks are at room temperature, start heating a cast iron skillet over medium high heat. Don’t use a non-stick pan as the high temperature you need to get it to will cause it to release toxic fumes. Generously salt and pepper both sides of the steaks and press the salt and pepper into the surface of the steaks to ensure it sticks.

When the skillet is very hot, place the steaks in the pan and allow them to brown undisturbed until they don’t stick to the pan anymore. Flip and brown for another few minutes on the other side.

Quickly put the pan in the hot oven and turn it off. Allow them to rest in the oven without opening it for 10 minutes for a rare steak, or 15 minutes for medium rare steak.

Transfer the steaks to a plate, then return the skillet to the stove over medium heat. Add a splash of olive oil and saute the minced shallots until they start getting soft. Add the mushrooms and continue to saute until they are limp and glossy and there is no liquid in the pan.

Add the cognac and swirl it around the bottom of the pan to deglaze. Add the chicken stock and raise the heat to high, boiling until it starts to thicken and there’s only about 1/4 C of liquid remaining. Push the mushrooms and shallots to the back half of the pan, then add the butter to the other half. Whisk vigorously to incorporate, then stir it all together. Squeeze a splash of lemon juice in and whisk to combine.

Serve the mushrooms and sauce over the steak.

Similar Recipes:

    • we totally char-grill spring onions too! it reminds me of what a calçot would taste like. i love how the inside of the "bulb" gets. great steak tips and i will def. agree to #1. plus the liberally salting and screaming hot cast iron pan, to me that will create the perfect steak. unfortuntely, 10 steaks in 10 days will make anyone not want to eat a certain something for a little bit (argentina did it), so steak will be waiting a few weeks for me to devour it once again.

      i actually ate an amazing steak in mushroom sauce in palermo, buenos aires last week and i think they actually blitz some dried hongos to a powder and sprinkled some of it in the cream sauce. the flavor was mushroomy-packed - intense, actually. i think i'm going to try it next time.
    • Lovely steaks. And ricing is totally the way to go for potatoes, no doubt! I have chef's block right now...just feeling uninspired. Got a boatload of ramps in the fridge I'm hoping will get me out of my funk. Thanks for this post, it makes me feel better that others go through it, too.
    • Marc, time permitting - I'll try your "set it & forget it" method. Also a nice way to work on a bottle of wine!

      The marbling on that steak looks awesome...surely a tasty steak.
    • Trudy
      Instead of a mushroom sauce(not a fan of the mushroom, I konw ridiculous, right?), do you have any recommendations for a leek or garlic sauce?
    • marc
      Sure, just replace the mushrooms, with leeks or ramps. You could also just leave them out and the sauce will still be good from the shallots and the fond on the pan.
    • Guys, I totally vouch for the charred onions. Marc made them at a dinner party once and they were literally assailed, along with the bowl of Romesco sauce he had prepared...
    • Jan
      The steaks look perfect and I'm loving the look of that mushroom sauce!
    • The steak looks perfectly done, restaurant style. Love the tips as well ^o^
    • Don't apologize for giving into the greasy take-out chow fun. My husband always like to admonish me that "there are times when you need bad Chinese food.'' I've come to realize he is actually right. ;)
    • So not mundane (I see I agree with everyone here). Having said that I hardly ever have steak. Now, (slightly hungover) your post is making me crave the stuff. I keep meaning to get myself a ricer but they're damn expensive! I quite like Marsala to deglaze after cooking a steak (it's funny, cognac always makes me think of Busta Rhymes or Snoop Dogg or something...)
    • Good, i'm glad to know i'm not the only one suffering from chef's-block once in a while. I thing i need help with stinging nettle. hehe.
      I like the use of Shimeji mushrooms there. Can't go wrong with a steak seared to perfection served with a mushroom sauce. A potato ricer is a must to make perfect gnocchi as well.
    • It's funny. It's only in this past year that I've become happy with making steak in the house. While I still prefer grilling, I've come to like this method of searing on cast iron pan then popping into oven. Now I just wish I had a proper hood vent, cause yesterday (I made a killer grass-fed ny strip steak) we ended up opening the doors to outside :) I finally went out and bought some more grapeseed oil so I had an oil that can handle high heat.
    • marc
      Yea, we have the same fake hood problem here. For steaks I put them in the pan dry which gives them a nicer crust and avoids the smoking problem.
    • Nothing wrong with getting back to basics! (And greasy Chinese food every once in a while!)
    • Love it - and yes, a ricer makes all the difference in the world!
    • I've never tried that technique for steak. Great idea!
    • Beautiful.
    • CB
      "Sear & Hold" to finish is my mantra for folks who cook steaks (and most other food!) on the grill. The best technique of any good cook - using the indoor or outdoor kitchen - is to know when to 'stop' cooking and just let things finish! Good advice, good recipe.
    • This sounds amazing, and far from uninspired. I often don't have the self-restraint to set my steak aside and make a sauce, but this one seems worth the effort. I'll try your method for perfect steak next time - it sounds like it'll work. It's a good point about the steak temperature. Great tip!
    • I can literally smell that dish right now...
    blog comments powered by Disqus

    Previous post:

    Next post: